Rainbow Pinwheel Cookies

Rainbow Pinwheel Cookies

Rated 5.0 Stars
(2)
31 PRINT PAGE SEE RECIPE

The holidays are, of course, sugar cookie season!

But if you’re like me, you’ve gotten bored with the old “roll, cut, sprinkle” routine. Luckily, a little food coloring is all takes to step up your sugar cookie game. Step it waaaay up!

rainbow pinwheel coookie recipe collage

The method for these Rainbow Pinwheel Cookies is so simple, and the process is made even easier when you start out with Better Crocker Sugar Cookie Mix.  Your favorite sugar cookie recipe will work just as well, but the way I look at it, with a mix, all the time I would have spent gathering and measuring out ingredients can be put towards making the cookies “pop” visually! (Call me shallow, but l love me a bling-y cookie . . .)

So, as I was saying, the technique for assembling Rainbow Pinwheel Cookies could not be easier (and thanks Creative Homemaker for the great idea!).  No precise measurement, rolling pin action, or squaring-off of dough blocks is required.

rainbow colored cookie dough

Combine your sugar cookie mix as directed.  Divide the dough into as many colors as you want, tint each appropriately (I used McCormick “Neon” shades for the pink, green, blue and purple, and then the yellow from the standard food coloring pack).

purple cookie dough balls

Roll each color of dough into little balls (about the size of a large grape – the mix yielded 14 of each color).

rainbow cookie balls

Then take a ball of each color, and quickly roll them into a cute little cookie dough “beachball”. (If the dough starts to get a little soft, pop the balls into the fridge for about 20 minutes before moving on to the next step.)

rainbow pinwheels

Next, roll this “beachball” out into a long strip (snake-style, from preschool), and, beginning at one end, roll the strip up, twisting as you go. The twisting is key: it’s what gives the cookies their zany candy-stripe, pinwheel effect.

rainbow pinwheels with sprinkles

Finally, dip the edges of the cookies in sprinkles and bake!

rainbow pinwheel recipe

Easy peasy!  Try this method in holiday colors or for themed parties. They’ll be a huge hit!

Hope you enjoy!  XO,

Michelle

Michelle Palm created the Jelly Shot Test Kitchen blog after discovering a lack of cocktail-style jelly shot recipes. Look for her posts here, and check her Tablespoon member profile often to see what she’s already gelled up!

Add a Comment
Please enter a comment.

Anonymous said:

I made these tonight. I used the betty crocker mix and it wouldnt even roll they were so sticky and messy. i must say it was fun but really messy. i had to just take a little color from each bowel and mix it in my hands and scoop it onto the cookie sheet. I will try addin flour next time but i still love this idea!


10/10/2012 10:45 PM
Anonymous said:

made these last night for my friends birthday! took me about 2 hours MAX start to finish? i added some flour to the dough when i put the food coloring in, which helped it firm up a bit. my cookies are MONSTER SIZED, but i love them. i also put the sprinkles over the whole cookie because they were too soft to roll the edges. oh, and im turning them into cookie sandwiches with buttercream in between :) thanks for this great idea


9/28/2012 9:49 AM
Anonymous said:

These were very sticky! I made them twice and had the same problem. It was very difficult to roll the dough into balls, let alone roll them into the “snakes” and wrap them. I put them in the fridge in between each step and, actually, broke each step into several sessions. Both times, it took me two plus hours to properly handle them without ending up with most of the dough on my hands. My house wasn’t necessarily hot, either, (about 75 degrees) so I don’t think heat was the problem. Suggestions?


7/12/2012 12:20 AM
Anonymous said:

My colors kept mixing into a gross mass and it seemed super sticky. Is that normal?


4/13/2012 4:24 PM
Anonymous said:

Made these for Easter tomorrow and had no problems! They look and taste great!


4/07/2012 3:17 PM
Anonymous said:

I just made these for Easter. I used another brand of cookie dough because I had it. My dough got really soft after adding the liquid coloring. If I make them again I will use paste colors. I had to put mine in the refrig. in between steps. I think because mine were a little soft my colors blended together a little more than the picture, but they are still cute. I had just made cupcakes so my kitchen was a little warm. I think the grandkids will like these and would have fun making them. Really clever idea. I felt like I was playing with play dough again. lol


4/07/2012 2:27 PM

Glad everyone is having fun with this recipe! Rauzy let us know how the paste color works … My sense is that given how much color goes into these, it might be extremely helpful and extend the working time! XO Michelle


3/25/2012 11:10 PM
Anonymous said:

Made these the other day to send to my grandkids in Ohio! They loved them! And yes, they do take some time to do, they’er kinda fun. I found that once I mixed the dough, separated it, added the food coloring (which the story I went to only had the Gel types), made the small balls and then finally combine those to make the ‘beachballs’ ~ If I put those balls in the fridge for about 20 minutes and let them get a little hard, they are much easier to handle! I was able to just take a couple of them out at a time and roll them into their snake shape and twirl. The twisting IS the hardest part but it is essential! Grandkids LOVED them!!


3/17/2012 1:52 PM
Rauzy said:

Perhaps try food paste instead of drops to color the dough? The drops change the consistency a bit, so food paste might work better for the stickiness. I haven’t made these yet, but think I will try food paste after reading the reviews:) Looks like a wonderfully fun recipe that my kids will love! Thanks for sharing.


3/09/2012 7:35 AM
Anonymous said:

Im making these right now… and the dough is almost impossible to roll for me. Spraying cooking spray on my hands is helping a little. and putting the dough in the freezer for 20mins or so. But once its out you only have 5 to 10 before it starts sicking again… Long process but its coming together.. Looking cute!


3/05/2012 7:00 PM
Anonymous said:

I don’t have Betty Crocker sugar cookie, can you make regular sugar cookie dough and carry out the same way?


1/31/2012 3:36 PM
Anonymous said:

OOOOPSS should have read more carefully, the direction includes sprinkle directionss..


1/30/2012 8:27 PM
Anonymous said:

Thanks for the great idea, so I gather from the picture if you want sprinkles on the edges you do that before you bake on the raw dough.?.

And how would you rate this 1-10 on diffuculty, Im 13 and don’t like starting and dropping a task.


1/30/2012 8:25 PM
SammyEmma said:

looke like i have to go shopping! have to make these


1/30/2012 9:27 AM
Anonymous said:

I am making these cookies now, and they are so fun! They do take a long time to prepare, though.


1/08/2012 2:51 PM
Anonymous said:
1/07/2012 5:45 PM
Anonymous said:

These are so pretty!


1/06/2012 12:22 PM
Anonymous said:

Husband is going duck hunting next week I am going to make these as “Camo”Cookies. Thank you for the idea


1/04/2012 7:52 AM
Anonymous said:

I couldnt get the dough to work at all… it would probably work better with freezer cookie dough because after working 45 minutes to get these to work i just scrapped the whole project


12/24/2011 7:59 PM
Anonymous said:

just finished making these! soo cute! very easy to make, didnt have any trouble! thanks


12/23/2011 10:51 AM
Anonymous said:

Looks like the spinning rainbow ball of death on my computer before it locks up


12/22/2011 9:17 PM

I just finished putting my balls in the fridge. This recipe is adorable, but takes a little work. The dough is sticky and kept sticking to my fingers and the measuring spoon. But seeing those colors makes me excited to bake them. I might even put some on a stick!


12/21/2011 5:32 PM

Hi sunshine223304, it is best to work quickly with the dough. I probably should have been clearer on that in the article – but since I’m always on deadline, I’m always a little behind, it seems, so didn’t think much about it . . . hope your cookies came out cute! XO Michelle


12/21/2011 1:39 PM

Thank you so much Michelle for sharing the wonderful recipe!!.. When I tried to make them, I had a really hard time with the dough getting soft. I put in the refrigerator for 20 minutes then it seemed like it got real soft again fast.. Did this happen to you?? :) Just curious! Maybe I am messing something up lol :)


12/20/2011 8:02 PM

Thanks everyone for your sweet comments! These were so fun to make, and I am so happy you are enjoying them too!


xblondie101091x, regarding the number of drops of food coloring, it varied by color, and we added a few drops at a time, but I would guess around 8 for most of the colors – we were going for VIBRANT!


XOXOX Michelle


12/16/2011 9:07 AM
Anonymous said:

What a fantastic idea on a classic sugar cookie I’m going to make these for my kids Birthdays next Summer :)


12/16/2011 8:44 AM

how many drops of food coloring do you put for each color?


12/15/2011 7:04 PM
Anonymous said:

Love it! thank you for share! :)


12/15/2011 5:19 PM
macheesmo said:

These are amazing Michelle! Nice work!


12/15/2011 5:06 PM
Anonymous said:

I think these are the most fun cookies I have ever seen!


12/14/2011 7:09 PM
Anonymous said:

This is very much what I did for my daughter’s Gay-Straight Alliance fundraiser, only I didn’t think to add the twist — what a great idea! They are SO easy to do and kids of all ages can’t resist them! (=


12/14/2011 3:07 PM
See something fishy? Let us know. We'll take down any content that violates our Community Rules.Report abuse